Skip to content
chasepost

chasepost

Built General Tough

Primary Menu chasepost

chasepost

  • Technology
  • Home
  • Fashion
  • Education
  • Business
  • Automotive
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • Lawyer: Doctors who sued CHCC, RHC have constitutional right to jury trial | News
  • General

Lawyer: Doctors who sued CHCC, RHC have constitutional right to jury trial | News

Janelle B. Smith March 31, 2022

DOCTORS Francois Claassens and James Toskas want their case heard by an impartial jury, said attorney Tiberius Mocanu who represents them in their lawsuit against the Commonwealth Healthcare Corporation and the Rota Health Center.

“The Government wants to protect its coffers and it thinks that it will have a better chance doing so with this court as the trier of fact than a jury. Nevertheless, the Government can rest assured that the downside liability it faces is identical with this court or with a jury. Conversely, Dr. Toskas and Dr. Claassens have a constitutional right to a jury trial; a right this Court has previously affirmed. It should again,” said Mocanu, in response to the Office of the Attorney General’s objection to the demand of the doctors to hold a jury trial on Rota.

In 2017, Claassens and Toskas sued RHC and CHCC for compensation for work performed beyond their normal schedules, claiming breach of contract and quantum meruit, a Latin term meaning “what one has earned” or “reasonable value of services.”

The doctors are alleging that CHCC and RHC failed to pay them for administrative leave accruement totaling $635,187. In May 2018, Superior Court Associate Judge Joseph N. Camacho dismissed their claims, saying that no one authorized Claassens and Toskas to obtain additional compensation for working extra hours.

But the doctors appealed and on Aug. 2, 2021, the CNMI Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s ruling and remanded the lawsuit for further proceedings.

On Jan. 7, 2022, CHCC and RHC, through Assistant Attorneys General John P. Lowrey and Stephen T. Anson, filed a notice objecting to the plaintiffs’ demand for a jury trial.

“Defendants have not consented to the jury trial demand, and instead conveyed to the Court during the January 4, 2022 status conference that the dispute could be resolved through dispositive motions following the conclusion of discovery,” the government lawyers said.

To clear up any confusion, they added, “defendants file this instant notice to clarify the record that defendants object to plaintiffs’ jury trial demand and that plaintiffs otherwise lack a right to a jury trial for their claims against the Commonwealth.”

According to the government lawyers, “A jury trial is otherwise unavailable to the plaintiffs asserting their specific claims against CHCC under the Commonwealth Code.”

They added, “Claims concerning an express or implied contract with the Commonwealth government are one of the types of actions specified in 7 CMC § 2251(b). 7 CMC § 2251 applies to CHCC as a public corporation to the same extent it applies to the Commonwealth itself 7 CMC § 2211. 7 CMC § 2253 further confirms that all actions brought against the Commonwealth ‘shall be tried by the court without a jury.’”

The Commonwealth “may waive the provisions of 7 CMC § 2253 in a particular case, and may demand a trial by jury to the same extent as a private party would be entitled to do so,” they said.

However, in this instance, “defendants do not waive the certain foregoing provisions of the Commonwealth Code and do not consent to a jury trial,” the government lawyers said.

“To the extent this dispute cannot be resolved through a dispositive motion, it must be resolved at a bench trial instead of a jury trial,” they added.

But in his opposition to the government’s objection to his client’s jury trial demand, Mocanu said this court has found the Government Liability Act’s provision prohibiting a jury trial unconstitutional.

“The court reasoned that purely economic reasons such as protecting the Commonwealth’s coffers and protecting public employment were not compelling enough reasons to withstand a strict scrutiny review. As such the court held that the substitution provision, the prohibition on punitive damages, and the restriction on jury trials were all unconstitutional,” Mocanu said.

The government argued that the Commonwealth has an interest against runaway jury verdicts, which could subject the government to unlimited liability, he said.

“However, the narrow interest of protecting the Commonwealth’s coffers is not protected simply by eliminating jury trials, it is protected by damage caps, prohibiting punitive damages, and attorney’s fees. Here, Dr. Toskas and Dr. Claassens are not claiming punitive damages and did not ask for attorney fees. Instead, all they are asking for is that their case be heard by an impartial jury.”

The government’s stated interest, whether examined under rational basis or strict scrutiny, is moot as the jury can award no more money than this court, Mocanu said.

“The damage caps applicable to this case already solve for the Government’s stated interest in the GLA [or the Government Liability Act]. Having this case tried by this court, as opposed to a jury, has no impact on the Government’s coffers,” the lawyer added.

Post Navigation

Previous NY attorney general wants subpoena enforced against Trump, eldest children in civil investigation
Next Helping smaller enterprises be green with finance – Opinion

More Stories

The News for December 2nd, 2022
  • General

The News for December 2nd, 2022

Janelle B. Smith July 9, 2024 0
How To Learn Japanese For Beginners – Personal Tips! |
  • General

How To Learn Japanese For Beginners – Personal Tips! |

Janelle B. Smith July 8, 2024 0
Si3D Cerabide – A Revolution In Sealant Technology From Nanolex
  • General

Si3D Cerabide – A Revolution In Sealant Technology From Nanolex

Janelle B. Smith July 5, 2024 0
July 2025
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Jun    

Archives

  • June 2025
  • April 2025
  • February 2025
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • December 2016

Categories

  • Beauty
  • Business & Finance
  • Car & Automotive
  • Computer & Technology
  • Fashion & Shopping
  • Food & Cooking
  • General
  • Health
  • Health & Fitness
  • Home & Improvement
  • Latest News Place
  • Law & Legal
  • Science & Education
  • Travel & Leisure

Recent Posts

  • Do You Really Need Different Cleansers For Day & Night?
  • Creating Digital Spaces That Move Property Forward
  • Henri Alexander Levy: Art Meets Enfants Riches Déprimés
  • The Benefits of Using a Horse Exerciser: Improved Health and Well-being
  • Spring into Love with These Floral-Inspired Ruby Engagement Rings

Fiverr

Fiverr Logo

Tags

American Express Business Cards Att Business Customer Service Att Business Internet Att Business Login Bad Business Codes Bank Of America Small Business Buffalo Business First Business Business Administration Jobs Business Administration Salary Business Analyst Jobs Business Card Dimensions Business Casual Female Business Casual For Women Business Casual Women Outfits Business Ideas 2021 Business Letter Example Business License California Business Name Search Business Process Reengineering Business Proposal Template Buy A Business Card For Business Chase For Business Chase Ink Business Card Columbia Business School Costco Business Center San Jose Emirates Business Class Facebook Business Account Fictitious Business Name Florida Business Entity Search Ga Sos Business Search Georgia Business Search Google Business Email Houston Business Journal Illinois Business Search Instagram Business Account Is Lularoe Still In Business London Business School Marketing Master Of Business Administration Men'S Business Casual Pittsburgh Business Times Qualified Business Income Deduction Sacramento Business Journal
bizorium
stylemondo

You may have missed

Do You Really Need Different Cleansers For Day & Night?
  • Beauty

Do You Really Need Different Cleansers For Day & Night?

Janelle B. Smith June 29, 2025
Creating Digital Spaces That Move Property Forward
  • Fashion & Shopping

Creating Digital Spaces That Move Property Forward

Janelle B. Smith April 9, 2025
Henri Alexander Levy: Art Meets Enfants Riches Déprimés
  • Fashion & Shopping

Henri Alexander Levy: Art Meets Enfants Riches Déprimés

Janelle B. Smith February 11, 2025
The Benefits of Using a Horse Exerciser: Improved Health and Well-being
  • Fashion & Shopping

The Benefits of Using a Horse Exerciser: Improved Health and Well-being

Janelle B. Smith November 26, 2024
Spring into Love with These Floral-Inspired Ruby Engagement Rings
  • Fashion & Shopping

Spring into Love with These Floral-Inspired Ruby Engagement Rings

Janelle B. Smith November 25, 2024
chasepost.net | CoverNews by AF themes.

WhatsApp us